Saturday, June 16, 2012

Hegel: §1-5

Hegel: §1-5


Conclusion:
The conscious is not only manifested by thought but of feelings, perception, or mental images. With this we have knowledge

 “The strictly human and thought-induced phenomena of consciousness do not originally appear in the form of a thought, but as a feeling, a perception, or mental image.” (20, 1)

Premise:
                 ·         It is though which marks the man off from the animals (20, 2).

o   These ideas would put feeling and thought so far apart as to make them opposites, and would represent them as so antagonistic, that feeling, particularly religious feeling, is supposed to be contaminated, perverted, and even annihilated by thought.

·         Thinking, under the guise of feeling, faith, or generalized image, has not been inactive: its action and its productions are there present and therein contained. (20, 2).

o   It is one thing to have such feelings and generalized images that have been moulded and permeated by thought, and another thing to have thoughts about them

·         Feelings, perception, &c. are the forms assumed by these contents. The contents remain one and the same, whether they are felt, seen, represented, or willed, and whether they are merely felt, or felt with an admixture of thought, or merely and simply thought (21, 3).

·         The several modes of feeling, perception, desire, and will, so far as we are aware of them, are in general called ideas and it may be roughly said, that philosophy puts thoughts, categories, or in more precise language, adequate notions, in the place of the generalized images we ordinarily call ideas (21, 3).

·         To get at the truth of any object or event, even of feelings, perceptions, opinions, and mental ideas, we must think it over. Now in any case to think things over is at least to transform feelings, ordinary ideas, & c., into thoughts (22, 5).

3 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The first premise,’ might be better used after an explanation of the two different thoughts is explained.

    • “But it is one thing to have such feelings and generalized images that have been moulded and permeated by thought, and another thing to have thoughts about them (20,3).

    Hegel is suggesting that human knowledge comes from the conscious, which is more than feelings, perception and mental images. It is our distinct ability to deal with thoughts as thoughts and bring them into consciousness that marks the man off from the animals (20, 2-3).

    ReplyDelete
  3. The argument outline does seem to cover all of the main premises of this reading selection. Additionally, it is interesting to note the second half of section 5, in which Hegel pays special attention to the alleged pervasive presence of consciousness among all people. "For philosophy alone," says Hegel, "it seems to be imagined, such study, care, and application are not in the least requisite" (Hegel 23 §5). Insofar as this selection is the introduction to the work, Hegel's approach to thought / philosophy lays a crucial foundation for how he will go about investigating the metaphysical problems later in his work.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.