Thursday, July 12, 2012

Commentary: §321-329 It is a citizen's duty to go to war and defend this individuality of the state from foreign states.

 The question then is why is it a citizens duty to go to war to defend the individuality of a state?

    
The premise refers to the bond of an individual to that of the state he is part of. As being part of that state, you should have an obligation to protect that state of it individualism from outside entities such as foreign states in order to preserve its individualism.
What makes an individual a citizen? The book definition is a legal recognized subject or national of state or commonwealth, either native or naturalized. It is agreeing to live in a particular state and follow its law. When you decide to inhabit a state and agree to follow its laws, in return, one should try to protect the individual rights and welfare. Essentially, it is a contract.
The individuals of a state are what make up that state. Every individual brings life and character, which encompasses a state.  The state is in actuality, a part of the individual. Since the state is in part, part of the individual, they should protect the state with its life as if it were their own. Even if that should result in all out war.
The sacrifice of one’s self to the state in order to protect its individuality acts as a bond or tie to that state. A subset of this premise is sacrifice on behalf of the state's individuality is a substantial tie between the state and its members (325/300). With this tie, it is only natural to state that the individual becomes part of the whole that is the state. In addition, one should feel obliged to want to protect something that is a part of them.
It is also said to protect ones state is to be courageous, and risking your life even in the face of certain death is necessary. Hegel states that to be courageous is to be free. By sacrificing yourself for the individuality of the state in itself is protecting the individuality of all citizens, this thought can be liberating. Giving one’s self for a higher purpose is self-gratifying no matter the individual motive.
With the contract between the individual and the state it is fair to say that one should want to protect what is believed to be in their best interest. In this inference, it is in the best interest of the individual to protect it states’ individuality from foreign states. This is important because as stated earlier the individual and the state have a bond, so ultimately by protecting the state’s individuality you are in return protecting the individual’s individuality as well.

1 comment:

  1. Nice using the class of contract theory to your advantage, go poli philo, i like this commentary a lot. the only crucial connection you had to make was that Hegel says to be courageous is to be free, thats some awesome shit, that connects a lot of stuff together. if it were that easy to be free the social contract would be a lot easier to maintain though dont you think? freedom is far more (and less) than being courageous

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.