"The principals asserted in these pages must be generally admitted as the basis for discussion of details before a consistent application of them to all the various departments of government and morals can be attempted with any prospect of advantage (p 93)."
Premises:
1. This section does not contain applications to adhere to but examples of applications (p 93).
2. These applications should help to clarify the proper use of the maxims that make up the whole argument of "On Liberty" (p 93).
3. Each example set forth will show how the maxims of "On Liberty" should be applied to each one (p 93).
4. These examples of application are pushed forth in hopes to "perfect" the use of the maxims before proper application for the best effect can ensue (p 93).
5. These examples will also help to dispel some of the arguments against the maxims set forth in "On Liberty" and will bolster the argument of the maxims set forth (I).
6. The following maxims are to be the guiding principals that the example of application should adhere to for argument's sake (p 93)
7. Maxim 1: The individual in matters that concern only himself is not accountable to society (p 93).
a) "Advice, instruction, persuasion, and avoidance" are the only "measures" that can be taken by society if deemed justified to show dislike of action toward the individual (p 93).
8. Maxim 2: When actions of others are of concern then the individual is held accountable for his actions and can be imposed by the society or the state punishment if it is necessary for its protection (p 93).
Based on the premises presented on this argument we can therefor conclude the different and perhaps even contrarily opinions between The two Marxism argument. Marxism 2 would basically oppose Mill idea on liberty and limits on power to persecute based on thoughts and actions. When an act is affecting only the individual and not the society then there is no need to interfere by the the society according to Mill's idea and on the other hand Maxism 1 would oppose punishment because it is necessary to protect the society and the individual actions done on his or the society welfare as it was stated on premise 8 of the argument.
ReplyDeleteMaxim one of this argument is more interesting, in my opinion, than Maxim two. In his argument, Mill specifies that, "it must be by no means supposed, because damage, or probability of damage, to the interests of others can alone justify the interference of society, that therefore it always does justify such interference" (93). Mill seems to give the actor a great deal of liberty in regards to what society allows him or disallows him to do. For example, would Maxim one declare that if an actor is abusing heroin, that society cannot impose punishment because the actor is not directly harming society?
ReplyDeleteAlexa's comment also brings to light Mill's noting that there are some actions which, although harmful to the individual, are permissible if they bring benefits to society as a whole. He uses a particular example in which he argues that another man succeeding in business over his rival, while harming the rival, benefits society as a whole. While this may be true, I find that is somewhat of a contradiction with Mill's emphasis of conformity and "tyranny of the majority." It is impossible for "society to benefit as a whole" because a part of that whole will obviously find themselves not benefiting. While this may be necessary in the real world, it seems to be unrealistically shunned by Mill's argument against the tyranny of the majority.
ReplyDelete